Taxonomy triangle (continuous, comprehensive, immersive)

Fri, Jan 29, 2016

Readings

Assignment

Follow the assignment listed on bCourses about what decisions you would make if you were the project-lead on a big news story for an online publication. Which of the taxonomical classifications would you use? Link to list of news packages

Classification of news packages

We identified three categories for classifying multimedia news packages. These categories are not discrete, but include various levels of gradation based on a set of qualities that may be exhibited within each package.

CONTINUOUS COMPREHENSIVE IMMERSIVE

Continuous

Story packages that are continuous are characterized by a traditional linear structure with a beginning, middle, and end to the story. They also require one primary medium driving the story. Continuous stories are also tend to be more “lean-back” in nature, meaning there was often less interactivity than Comprehensive or Immersive stories. The idea is that the story is consumed mostly by reading or watching.

These are questions used to qualify a story’s level of continuousness (graded 1-5):

  1. The project is mostly one continuous narrative.
  2. This story has one primary media form (e.g. text, video) driving the narrative.
  3. This project is more of a “lean-back” or non-interactive experience.

Examples

  • The Verge story on John Wilkes Booth who may (or may not) have been killed after assassinating Lincoln. This story is integrates multimedia throughout a text-driven piece.
  • America Elect by The Guardian, which is a graphic-driven story that is told linearly.
  • Lost and Found which is a audio-photo driven story by NPR.

Comprehensive

A Comprehensive package presents an in-depth environment that contains multiple separate elements of a story under a common umbrella, like a topic page. Instead of a linear narrative that drives the users through a singular experience, the story is broken up into sections. A story package may include segments such as profiles, background information, history, or future implications—some of which can be individually narrative.

Each segment is unique, and in many cases each section is told in the type of media most appropriate for the content in that segment. For example, a video is used for a segment of a story in which there is a lot of action or emotion, and graphics for a section that is informational or requires visual aids to explain complex subject matter.

These are questions used to qualify a story’s level of comprehensiveness (graded 1-5):

  1. This project is more about covering a topic than a single narrative story.
  2. This project is divided into sections or parts, intending for the user to jump around.
  3. This project is informational in nature.

Examples

  • America The Gutted by the GlobalPost, which is a news package composed of multiple different piece of multimedia. It tackles the topic of unemployment.
  • Planet Money Makes a T-Shirt by NPR, which is a package of video, text, and photos that tells the topic of a t-shirt in the global economy.

Immersive

Stories in the Immersive category create an environment, a space for the user to explore, and through this exploration the narrative unfolds itself. It’s an environment that is very engaging, and there is an high level of interactivity between the space and the users.

Linearity is not a prerequisite for this type of storytelling. The level of control the user had in directing the experience varies in these projects. Some Immersive news packages were like video games or choose-your-own-adventure stories, where users made choices that would determine their own experience. The experience varied from user to user based on the decisions made. Others packages were a very structured experiences with little more than a “next” button to advance the narrative through a unified path.

“Cinematic” is a term often associated with this category, and it makes sense. A striking commonality found in these projects was that most had some sort of initial start page displayed up front with a title, background information, and more importantly a button or link requesting action to initiate the experience—similar to a DVD/Blu-ray start menu.

  1. This project is similar to a video game experience requiring lots of interactivity and/or takes up the full screen of the browser.
  2. This project begins with some type of launch-like element, like a play button, to initiate the experience.
  3. This project uses audiovisual media to create an immersive environment.

Examples

  • Out My Window by NFB, which is an interactive piece as part of a larger Highrise theme of stories they did.
  • Killing Kennedy by National Geographic, which is an accompaniment to a documentary NatGeo did of the same name, and based on a book by Bill O’Reilly.
  • Balloons of Bhutan by Johnathan Harris, which is an artistic project about discovering happiness among the Bhutanese people in the Himalayas.

Intersections

Intersections include any number of project that comprise two or more qualities from our classifications system. A continuous-immersive for example, or a comprehensive-immersive.

Here are a few examples:

  • SnowFall by the New York Times. Arguably, the watershed project that defined a new form of multimedia storytelling on the web.
  • Firestorm by The Guardian, which paired a documentary filmmaker, designer, and writer to create an piece about brushfires in Tasmania.
  • NSA Files: Decoded also by The Guardian. The Pulitzer-winning piece covered an exhaustive topic, but kept a linear path through most of the piece.